CardRewards.aiCardRewards
  • Browse cards
  • Compare
  • Best cards
  • Rewards programs
Search for “Sheetz”
Search for “Sheetz”
Sign InSign Up

Best Credit Cards for Sheetz

Ranked by real value with filters for fees, issuers, rewards, and transfer programs.

CardRewards.ai helps you find the best credit card for your spending with data-driven recommendations, side-by-side comparisons, and expert analysis.

© Copyright 2026 CardRewards. All Rights Reserved.

About
  • About
  • FAQ
  • Contact
Browse
  • Credit Cards
  • Compare
  • Best cards
  • Benefits
  • Issuers
  • Programs
  • Lounges
  • Brands
Product
  • Credit Cards
  • Sitemap
Legal
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Accessibility

Editorial disclosure: CardRewards.ai is an independent comparison service. Card data comes from issuers' published terms; data as of September 27, 2026. Card issuers do not influence our rankings or content.

Results from

$6,000

Scoring mode

Options

Point valuation

Booking

Rewards

Programs

Networks

Refine results

How do you usually dine?

Do you use DashPass or Uber One?

Do you use Resy for reservations?

No annual fee only?

Avoid Amex network?

Best Credit Cards for Sheetz

Ranked by real value with filters for fees, issuers, rewards, and transfer programs.

Resolved as:DiningMerchant: Sheetz+1 moreCached
95%
Not right? Try:
174 matches911ms

Rankings are generated by our algorithm based on earn rates, point valuations, fees, and benefits — not paid placement. We don't accept compensation to rank cards higher. How we rank

Chase Sapphire Preferred Card
1

Chase Sapphire Preferred Card

Chase

3x Ultimate Rewards on Dining
3x × 1.8¢/pt = 5.4¢ per dollar

Why this card

  1. 1.3x on Dining — points worth 1.8¢ each ($324/yr on $6,000 spend)
  2. 2.Auto Rental Coverage
  3. 3.Auto Rental Collision Damage Waiver
  4. 4.Complimentary 4th night at Ennismore Hotel properties
  5. 5.$25/yr $100 Annual Hotel Credit
VISACore Rate
5.4¢
per dollar on dining
$95/yr($14.40 in credits)
Annual rewards$324
+ Credits$14.40
− Annual fee$95
Net annual value$243.40
2

Bilt Palladium Card

Cardless

2x Bilt Rewards on Dining
2x × 2.2¢/pt = 4.4¢ per dollar

Why this card

  1. 1.$200/yr $400 Bilt Travel Hotel credit
  2. 2.Priority Pass Airport Lounge Access
  3. 3.MasterRental Coverage
  4. 4.Mastercard Travel & Lifestyle Services
MASTERCARD
4.4¢
per dollar on dining
$495/yr
Annual rewards$264.00
− Annual fee$495
Net annual value-$231.00
Citi Strata Premier Card
3

Citi Strata Premier Card

Citi

3x ThankYou Points on Dining
3x × 1.6¢/pt = 4.8¢ per dollar

Why this card

  1. 1.3x on Dining — points worth 1.6¢ each ($288/yr on $6,000 spend)
  2. 2.$60/yr Annual Hotel Savings Benefit
  3. 3.$20/yr Lyft Credits
  4. 4.$15/yr Mastercard Transit Benefit
  5. 5.MasterRental Coverage (Car Rental Insurance)
MASTERCARDCore Rate
4.8¢
per dollar on dining
$95/yr
Annual rewards$288
− Annual fee$95
Net annual value$193
4

Capital One Venture X Rewards Credit Card

Capital One

2x Venture Miles on Dining
2x × 1.9¢/pt = 3.7¢ per dollar

Why this card

  1. 1.Primary Auto Rental Collision Damage Waiver
  2. 2.$240/yr $300 Annual Capital One Travel Credit
  3. 3.Priority Pass Lounge Access
  4. 4.Capital One Lounge Access
  5. 5.Partner Lounge Network
VISA
3.7¢
per dollar on dining
$395/yr
Annual rewards$222
− Annual fee$395
Net annual value-$173
5

PenFed Platinum Rewards Visa Signature® Card

Penfed

5x points on Dining

Why this card

  1. 1.5x on Dining ($252/yr on $6,000 spend)
  2. 2.Auto Rental Collision Damage Waiver
  3. 3.OpenTable Special Dining Events
  4. 4.Visa Signature Rental Car Privileges
  5. 5.$5/yr Booking.com Travel Credits
VISACore Rate
4.2¢
per dollar on dining
No annual fee
Annual rewards$252
Net annual value$252
6

Wyndham Rewards Earner Plus Card

Barclays

6x Wyndham Rewards on Dining
6x × 0.7¢/pt = 4.2¢ per dollar

Why this card

  1. 1.6x on Dining — points worth 0.7¢ each ($218.40/yr on $6,000 spend)
  2. 2.Annual Bonus
  3. 3.Auto Rental Collision Damage Waiver
  4. 4.OpenTable Special Dining Events
  5. 5.Visa Signature Rental Car Privileges
VISACore Rate
3.6¢
per dollar on dining
$95/yr
Annual rewards$218.40
− Annual fee$95
Net annual value$123.40
7

Sam's Club Mastercard

Synchrony

5% cash back on Dining

Why this card

  1. 1.5% cash back on Dining ($252/yr on $6,000 spend)

No annual fee

MASTERCARDCore Rate
4.2¢
per dollar on dining
No annual fee
Annual rewards$252
Net annual value$252

Bonus rate on first $6,000/annual, then base rate

American Express Gold Card
8

American Express Gold Card

Amex

4x Membership Rewards on Dining
4x × 1.5¢/pt = 6.0¢ per dollar

Why this card

  1. 1.4x on Dining — points worth 1.5¢ each ($198/yr on $6,000 spend)
  2. 2.$60/yr $120 Dining Credit
  3. 3.$60/yr $120 Uber Cash
  4. 4.$50/yr $100 Resy Credit
  5. 5.$42/yr $84 Dunkin' Credit
AMEXCore Rate
3.3¢
per dollar on dining
$325/yr
Annual rewards$198
− Annual fee$325
Net annual value-$127

Bonus rate on first $50,000/annual, then base rate

9

Verizon Visa Card

Synchrony

4% cash back on Dining

Why this card

  1. 1.4% cash back on Dining ($240/yr on $6,000 spend)
  2. 2.Auto Rental Collision Damage Waiver
  3. 3.OpenTable Special Dining Events
  4. 4.Visa Signature Rental Car Privileges
  5. 5.$5/yr Booking.com Travel Credits
VISACore Rate
4.0¢
per dollar on dining
No annual fee
Annual rewards$240
Net annual value$240
Citi Strata Elite℠ Card
10

Citi Strata Elite℠ Card

Citi

3x ThankYou Points on Dining
3x × 1.6¢/pt = 4.8¢ per dollar

Why this card

  1. 1.3x on Dining — points worth 1.6¢ each ($201.60/yr on $6,000 spend)
  2. 2.Priority Pass™ Select membership
  3. 3.$150/yr Up to $300 Annual Hotel Benefit
  4. 4.American Airlines Admirals Club® Lounge Access Passes
  5. 5.$72/yr Up to $120 Global Entry® or TSA PreCheck® Application Fee Credit
MASTERCARDCore Rate
3.4¢
per dollar on dining
$595/yr($597.50 in credits)
Annual rewards$201.60
+ Credits$597.50
− Annual fee$595
Net annual value$204.10
Bilt Obsidian Card
11

Bilt Obsidian Card

Cardless

3x Bilt Rewards on Dining
3x × 2.2¢/pt = 6.6¢ per dollar

Why this card

  1. 1.3x on Dining — points worth 2.2¢ each ($237.60/yr on $6,000 spend)
  2. 2.$20/yr $100 of Bilt Travel Hotel credit
  3. 3.$20/yr Lyft Credits
  4. 4.MasterRental Coverage
  5. 5.$15/yr Mastercard Transit Benefit
MASTERCARDCore Rate
4.0¢
per dollar on dining
$95/yr
Annual rewards$237.60
− Annual fee$95
Net annual value$142.60
H-D™ H.O.G.™ Elite Visa Signature®
12

H-D™ H.O.G.™ Elite Visa Signature®

Usbank

5x points on Dining

Why this card

  1. 1.5x on Dining ($228/yr on $6,000 spend)
  2. 2.Auto Rental Collision Damage Waiver
  3. 3.OpenTable Special Dining Events
  4. 4.Visa Signature Rental Car Privileges
  5. 5.$5/yr Booking.com Travel Credits
VISACore Rate
3.8¢
per dollar on dining
$99/yr($104.50 in credits)
Annual rewards$228
+ Credits$104.50
− Annual fee$99
Net annual value$233.50
U.S. Bank Altitude Connect Visa Signature Card
13

U.S. Bank Altitude Connect Visa Signature Card

Usbank

4x Usbank Altitude Rewards on Dining
4x × 1.0¢/pt = 4.0¢ per dollar

Why this card

  1. 1.4x on Dining — points worth 1.0¢ each ($192/yr on $6,000 spend)
  2. 2.Rental Car Damage Coverage
  3. 3.Auto Rental Collision Damage Waiver
  4. 4.$72/yr TSA PreCheck® or Global Entry®
  5. 5.$60/yr TSA PreCheck or Global Entry Credit

Your spend ($3,600) is 90% of the $4,000 annual cap

VISACore Rate
3.2¢
per dollar on dining
No annual fee
Annual rewards$192
Net annual value$192

Bonus rate on first $1,000/quarterly, then base rate

Wells Fargo Autograph Visa Credit Card
14

Wells Fargo Autograph Visa Credit Card

Wells Fargo

3x Wells Fargo Rewards on Dining
3x × 1.3¢/pt = 3.8¢ per dollar
Up to 4.8¢/$ (1.6¢/pt)via Choice Privileges

Why this card

  1. 1.3x on Dining — points worth 1.3¢ each ($225/yr on $6,000 spend)
  2. 2.Auto Rental Collision Damage Waiver
  3. 3.OpenTable Special Dining Events
  4. 4.Visa Signature Rental Car Privileges
  5. 5.$5/yr Booking.com Travel Credits
VISACore Rate
3.8¢
per dollar on dining
No annual fee
Annual rewards$225
Net annual value$225
BMO Premium Rewards Mastercard®
15

BMO Premium Rewards Mastercard®

Bmo

4x points on Dining

Why this card

  1. 1.4x on Dining ($240/yr on $6,000 spend)
MASTERCARDCore Rate
4.0¢
per dollar on dining
$95/yr
Annual rewards$240
− Annual fee$95
Net annual value$145

Bonus rate on first $2,000/quarterly, then base rate

16

Sam’s Club World Elite Mastercard® (Club members)

Synchrony

5% cash back on Dining

Why this card

  1. 1.5% cash back on Dining ($252/yr on $6,000 spend)
  2. 2.$20/yr Lyft Credits
  3. 3.$15/yr Mastercard Transit Benefit
  4. 4.$30/yr Instacart+ Savings
  5. 5.Mastercard Travel & Lifestyle Services

No annual fee

MASTERCARDCore Rate
4.2¢
per dollar on dining
No annual fee
Annual rewards$252
Net annual value$252

Bonus rate on first $6,000/annual, then base rate

Citi Strata Credit Card
17

Citi Strata Credit Card

Citi

3x ThankYou Points on Dining
3x × 1.6¢/pt = 4.8¢ per dollar

Why this card

  1. 1.3x on Dining — points worth 1.6¢ each ($249.60/yr on $6,000 spend)
  2. 2.$50/yr $300 Annual Travel Credit
  3. 3.Citi Travel®

No annual fee

MASTERCARDCore Rate
4.2¢
per dollar on dining
No annual fee
Annual rewards$249.60
Net annual value$249.60
Gemini Credit Card
18

Gemini Credit Card

Genesis Fs

4% cash back on Dining

Why this card

  1. 1.4% cash back on Dining ($216/yr on $6,000 spend)

No annual fee

Your spend ($3,600) is 100% of the $3,600 annual cap

MASTERCARDCore Rate
3.6¢
per dollar on dining
No annual fee
Annual rewards$216
Net annual value$216

Bonus rate on first $300/monthly, then base rate

19

USAA Cashback Rewards Plus American Express Card

Usaa

5% cash back on Dining

Why this card

  1. 1.5% cash back on Dining ($204/yr on $6,000 spend)

No annual fee

AMEXCore Rate
3.4¢
per dollar on dining
No annual fee
Annual rewards$204
Net annual value$204
IHG One Rewards Premier Credit Card
20

IHG One Rewards Premier Credit Card

Chase

5x IHG One Rewards on Dining
5x × 0.6¢/pt = 3.0¢ per dollar

Why this card

  1. 1.5x on Dining — points worth 0.6¢ each ($180/yr on $6,000 spend)
  2. 2.$72/yr Global Entry, TSA PreCheck or NEXUS Statement Credit
  3. 3.$30/yr Complimentary DashPass Membership
  4. 4.$20/yr Lyft Credits
  5. 5.$15/yr Mastercard Transit Benefit
MASTERCARDCore Rate
3.0¢
per dollar on dining
$99/yr
Annual rewards$180
− Annual fee$99
Net annual value$81
Bank of America Customized Cash Rewards Credit Card
21

Bank of America Customized Cash Rewards Credit Card

Bank Of America

3% cash back on Dining

Why this card

  1. 1.3% cash back on Dining ($180/yr on $6,000 spend)
  2. 2.Auto Rental Collision Damage Waiver
  3. 3.OpenTable Special Dining Events
  4. 4.Visa Signature Rental Car Privileges
  5. 5.$5/yr Booking.com Travel Credits
VISACore Rate
3.0¢
per dollar on dining
No annual fee
Annual rewards$180
Net annual value$180

Bonus rate on first $2,500/quarterly, then base rate

22

TD Cash Credit Card

Td Bank

3% cash back on Dining

Why this card

  1. 1.3% cash back on Dining ($180/yr on $6,000 spend)
  2. 2.Auto Rental Collision Damage Waiver
  3. 3.OpenTable Special Dining Events
  4. 4.Visa Signature Rental Car Privileges
  5. 5.$5/yr Booking.com Travel Credits
VISACore Rate
3.0¢
per dollar on dining
No annual fee
Annual rewards$180
Net annual value$180
Costco Anywhere Visa Card by Citi
23

Costco Anywhere Visa Card by Citi

Citi

4% cash back on Dining

Why this card

  1. 1.4% cash back on Dining ($216/yr on $6,000 spend)
  2. 2.Travel Accident Insurance

No annual fee

VISACore Rate
3.6¢
per dollar on dining
No annual fee
Annual rewards$216
Net annual value$216

Bonus rate on first $7,000/annual, then base rate

bp rewards Visa®
24

bp rewards Visa®

Fnbo

4% cash back on Dining

Why this card

  1. 1.4% cash back on Dining ($216/yr on $6,000 spend)

No annual fee

VISACore Rate
3.6¢
per dollar on dining
No annual fee
Annual rewards$216
Net annual value$216
25

One Key+ Card

Wells Fargo

3% cash back on Dining

Why this card

  1. 1.3% cash back on Dining ($180/yr on $6,000 spend)
  2. 2.Auto Rental Collision Damage Waiver
  3. 3.$20/yr Lyft Credits
  4. 4.$15/yr Mastercard Transit Benefit
  5. 5.$30/yr Instacart+ Savings
MASTERCARDCore Rate
3.0¢
per dollar on dining
$99/yr
Annual rewards$180
− Annual fee$99
Net annual value$81
26

Sam’s Club World Elite Mastercard® (Plus members)

Synchrony

5% cash back on Dining

Why this card

  1. 1.5% cash back on Dining ($252/yr on $6,000 spend)
  2. 2.$20/yr Lyft Credits
  3. 3.$15/yr Mastercard Transit Benefit
  4. 4.$30/yr Instacart+ Savings
  5. 5.Mastercard Travel & Lifestyle Services

No annual fee

MASTERCARDCore Rate
4.2¢
per dollar on dining
No annual fee
Annual rewards$252
Net annual value$252

Bonus rate on first $6,000/annual, then base rate

Chase Sapphire Reserve
27

Chase Sapphire Reserve

Chase

3x Ultimate Rewards on Dining
3x × 1.8¢/pt = 5.4¢ per dollar

Why this card

  1. 1.3x on Dining — points worth 1.8¢ each ($194.40/yr on $6,000 spend)
  2. 2.$240/yr Annual Travel Credit
  3. 3.$125/yr Select Hotels Credit (2026)
  4. 4.Air Canada Maple Leaf Lounge Access
  5. 5.Priority Pass Select Membership
VISACore Rate
3.2¢
per dollar on dining
$795/yr($18 in credits)
Annual rewards$194.40
+ Credits$18
− Annual fee$795
Net annual value-$582.60
28

Sam’s Club World Mastercard®

Synchrony

5% cash back on Dining

Why this card

  1. 1.5% cash back on Dining ($252/yr on $6,000 spend)

No annual fee

MASTERCARDCore Rate
4.2¢
per dollar on dining
No annual fee
Annual rewards$252
Net annual value$252

Bonus rate on first $6,000/annual, then base rate

29

MGM Rewards Iconic World Elite Mastercard®

Fnbo

2x MGM Rewards on Dining
2x × 1.0¢/pt = 2.0¢ per dollar

Why this card

  1. 1.2x on Dining — points worth 1.0¢ each ($120/yr on $6,000 spend)
  2. 2.$120/yr Resort Credit
  3. 3.$20/yr Lyft Credits
  4. 4.$15/yr Mastercard Transit Benefit
  5. 5.Global Entry or TSA PreCheck®
MASTERCARDCore Rate
2.0¢
per dollar on dining
$249/yr
Annual rewards$120
− Annual fee$249
Net annual value-$129
Bank of America® Customized Cash Rewards for Students
30

Bank of America® Customized Cash Rewards for Students

Bank Of America

3% cash back on Dining

Why this card

  1. 1.3% cash back on Dining ($180/yr on $6,000 spend)
  2. 2.Auto Rental Collision Damage Waiver
  3. 3.OpenTable Special Dining Events
  4. 4.Visa Signature Rental Car Privileges
  5. 5.$5/yr Booking.com Travel Credits
VISACore Rate
3.0¢
per dollar on dining
No annual fee
Annual rewards$180
Net annual value$180

Bonus rate on first $2,500/quarterly, then base rate