Goomba Johnny's Pizzeria

Name: Goomba Johnny's Pizzeria
Address: 374 Mooney Pond Rd, Farmingville, NY, 11738, US
Telephone: +16317360722
Price range: $$

PizzaItalian$$Suffolk

$$ · Moderate
Reservations not listed
374 Mooney Pond Rd
Farmingville, NY 11738
+16317360722
Website

Ways to pay here

What each card earns on your bill, best first.

Your bill$

Top dining cards

Best nowAmerican Express Gold Card
$325 annual fee
4x on up to $50,000 of eligible spend a year
≈$6.00
6%
With Rakuten Dining: ≈$11.50 · 12%
4x Membership Rewards on dining
400 Membership Rewards · ≈$6.00 at 1.5¢ each (valuation from Aug 2025)
After you join Rakuten Dining and link this card
Rakuten Dining, Member tier: 5% back
$5.50 as points, or $5.00 as cash (valuation from Oct 2026)
Valued as points, for members who take Rakuten Cash Back as Bilt points (free Bilt account; 50 points per $1 at Blue status, 100 per $1 from Silver up) or Amex Membership Rewards (1:1; needs another Amex card that earns Membership Rewards). Taken as cash, it is worth its face value.
A card links to one Rakuten (Rewards Network and Seated) program at a time; linking it to Rakuten Dining replaces any other.
Join Rakuten Dining
Chase Sapphire Preferred Card
$95 annual fee
≈$5.40
5.4%
With Rakuten Dining: ≈$10.90 · 11%
3x Chase Ultimate Rewards on dining
300 Chase Ultimate Rewards · ≈$5.40 at 1.8¢ each (valuation from Jan 2026)
After you join Rakuten Dining and link this card
Rakuten Dining, Member tier: 5% back
$5.50 as points, or $5.00 as cash (valuation from Oct 2026)
Valued as points, for members who take Rakuten Cash Back as Bilt points (free Bilt account; 50 points per $1 at Blue status, 100 per $1 from Silver up) or Amex Membership Rewards (1:1; needs another Amex card that earns Membership Rewards). Taken as cash, it is worth its face value.
A card links to one Rakuten (Rewards Network and Seated) program at a time; linking it to Rakuten Dining replaces any other.
Join Rakuten Dining
Chase Sapphire Reserve
$795 annual fee
≈$5.40
5.4%
With Rakuten Dining: ≈$10.90 · 11%
3x Chase Ultimate Rewards on dining
300 Chase Ultimate Rewards · ≈$5.40 at 1.8¢ each (valuation from Jan 2026)
After you join Rakuten Dining and link this card
Rakuten Dining, Member tier: 5% back
$5.50 as points, or $5.00 as cash (valuation from Oct 2026)
Valued as points, for members who take Rakuten Cash Back as Bilt points (free Bilt account; 50 points per $1 at Blue status, 100 per $1 from Silver up) or Amex Membership Rewards (1:1; needs another Amex card that earns Membership Rewards). Taken as cash, it is worth its face value.
A card links to one Rakuten (Rewards Network and Seated) program at a time; linking it to Rakuten Dining replaces any other.
Join Rakuten Dining

Values are estimates at CardRewards point valuations. See the best cards for dining.

Best now≈6%American Express Gold Card

About

Italian pizzeria serving New York-style pizza, with gluten-free pizza and vegetarian selections, for pickup or delivery.

Goomba Johnny's Pizzeria offers Italian food, including New York-style pizza.

Gluten-free pizza and several vegetarian selections are available, and you can order for pickup, delivery, or takeout.

Known for

New York-style pizza
Gluten-free pizza
Vegetarian selections
Pickup and delivery

Dining programs here

12 dining programs pay extra here on top of your card. Join one, link a card, and pay with that card.

Hilton (Rewards Network): pick one of 11 programs

These programs share one restaurant network, and a card can be linked to only one of them. Choose the currency you want. Every day.

Hilton Honors Dining2–8 points per $1
IHG Dine & Earn1–8 points per $1
Eat Around Town4–6 points per $1
AAdvantage Dining1–5 miles per $1
SkyMiles Dining0.5–5 miles per $1
MileagePlus Dining0.5–5 miles per $1
Atmos Rewards Dining0.5–5 points per $1
Dine Out with Wyndham1–5 points per $1
Rakuten Dining5% back
TrueBlue Dining1–3 points per $1
Rapid Rewards Dining0.5–3 points per $1

Bilt Dining
1 point per $1
Bilt Rewards · Every day
How Bilt Dining works

Hours

Monday	11 AM – 9 PM
Tuesday	11 AM – 9 PM
Wednesday	11 AM – 9 PM
Thursday	11 AM – 9 PM
Friday	11 AM – 9 PM
Saturday	11 AM – 9 PM
Sunday	11 AM – 9 PM

Location

374 Mooney Pond Rd · Suffolk, Farmingville

Directions Apple Maps

Details

Features

Gluten-free options
Vegetarian friendly

Good for

Dinner · Lunch

Nearby restaurants

Rio Douro
up to12%
Italian · $$$$ · Suffolk · 1.5 mi
American Express Gold Card + Rakuten Dining
Hilton Honors Dining8xIHG Dine & Earn8xEat Around Town6x+9 more
Rio Douro
up to12%
Farmingville · 1.6 mi
American Express Gold Card + Upside
Upside6%
La Cucina Paisanos
up to8.8%
Italian · $$$ · Suffolk · 1.6 mi
American Express Gold Card + Eat Around Town
Hilton Honors Dining8xIHG Dine & Earn8xEat Around Town6x+7 more
Applebee's - 206
up to16%
American · Farmingville · 2.1 mi
American Express Gold Card + Upside
Upside29%

1 Pizza places in Farmingville 3 restaurants in Suffolk

Some restaurant addresses, phone numbers, websites and cuisines come from Overture Maps Foundation open data (Meta and Microsoft, CDLA Permissive 2.0; Foursquare, Apache 2.0; AllThePlaces, CC0 1.0). Overture attribution Some neighbourhoods come from Who's On First boundaries (CC-BY 4.0). Who's On First licenses Some opening hours, phone numbers, websites and cuisines are © OpenStreetMap contributors (ODbL 1.0). OpenStreetMap copyright