552 Italian restaurants in New York that earn more on your cards

New York has 552 Italian restaurants in our listings: 313 take a dining program and 325 have a card perk. Most common price: $$ (moderate). Top neighborhoods: West Village (33), Midtown East (21), and Upper East Side (21).

552 restaurants

  • Italian · $$ · Flatiron

    American Express Gold Card

    Resy credit
  • Italian · $ · Park Slope

    American Express Gold Card

    Resy credit
  • Pastai

    up to6%

    Italian · $$ · Chelsea

    American Express Gold Card

    Resy credit
  • Pastavino

    up to6%

    Italian · $$$ · St. George

    American Express Gold Card

    Resy credit
  • Pepolino

    up to6%

    Italian · $$ · Tribeca

    American Express Gold Card

    Resy credit
  • Piacere

    up to6%

    Italian · $$ · Nolita

    American Express Gold Card

    Resy credit
  • Italian · $$ · Nolita

    American Express Gold Card

    Resy credit
  • Pisticci

    up to6%

    Italian · $ · Morningside Heights

    American Express Gold Card

    Resy credit
  • Pizza 4P's

    up to6%

    Italian · $ · Greenpoint

    American Express Gold Card

    Resy credit
  • Popina NYC

    up to6%

    Italian · $$ · Cobble Hill

    American Express Gold Card

    Resy credit
  • Italian · $ · Brooklyn

    American Express Gold Card

    Resy credit
  • Recente

    up to6%

    Italian · $ · East Village

    American Express Gold Card

    Resy credit
  • RIALTO

    up to6%

    Italian · $ · Astoria

    American Express Gold Card

    Resy credit
  • Ribalta

    up to6%

    Italian · $$ · Greenwich Village

    American Express Gold Card

    Resy credit
  • Italian · $$ · Boerum Hill

    American Express Gold Card

    Resy credit
Restaurants
552
Neighborhoods
147
Cuisines
31
Dining programs
14
With a card perk
325

The 3 best cards to bring to dinner in New York

Ranked by what each card earns across this city's restaurants at our point valuations, counting the dining program that pays most at each one. Card credits aren't counted. Bilt Dining (207 restaurants) and Rakuten Dining (176) are the most widespread dining programs here, out of 552 restaurants. American Express Gold Card tops the list here on its own dining rate — ≈$6.00 on a $100 dinner before any program.

All the best cards for dining

14 dining programs that pay in New York

Dining programs pay on top of your card. Join one, link a card, and every meal at a participating restaurant earns twice.

30 cuisines in New York

Italian in 147 New York neighborhoods

398 more cities and towns in New York

Some restaurant addresses, phone numbers, websites and cuisines come from Overture Maps Foundation open data (Meta and Microsoft, CDLA Permissive 2.0; Foursquare, Apache 2.0; AllThePlaces, CC0 1.0). Overture attribution Some neighbourhoods come from Who's On First boundaries (CC-BY 4.0). Who's On First licenses Some opening hours, phone numbers, websites and cuisines are © OpenStreetMap contributors (ODbL 1.0). OpenStreetMap copyright

Editorial disclosure: CardRewards.ai is an independent comparison service. Card data comes from issuers' published terms; catalog last published October 12, 2026, and each card page shows when its terms were last checked. Card issuers do not influence our rankings or content.