O'Toole's Irish Pub & Grill

Name: O'Toole's Irish Pub & Grill
Address: 4796 West Broad St, Columbus, OH, 43228, US
Telephone: +16148786461
Price range: $$

IrishBar/Pub FareAmerican$$South Columbus

$$ · Moderate
Reservations not listed
4796 West Broad St
Columbus, OH 43228
+16148786461
Website
Menu

Ways to pay here

What each card earns on your bill, best first.

Your bill$

Top dining cards

Best nowAmerican Express Gold Card
$325 annual fee
4x on up to $50,000 of eligible spend a year
≈$6.00
6%
With Rakuten Dining: ≈$11.50 · 12%
4x Membership Rewards on dining
400 Membership Rewards · ≈$6.00 at 1.5¢ each (valuation from Aug 2025)
After you join Rakuten Dining and link this card
Rakuten Dining, Member tier: 5% back
$5.50 as points, or $5.00 as cash (valuation from Oct 2026)
Valued as points, for members who take Rakuten Cash Back as Bilt points (free Bilt account; 50 points per $1 at Blue status, 100 per $1 from Silver up) or Amex Membership Rewards (1:1; needs another Amex card that earns Membership Rewards). Taken as cash, it is worth its face value.
A card links to one Rakuten (Rewards Network and Seated) program at a time; linking it to Rakuten Dining replaces any other.
Join Rakuten Dining
Chase Sapphire Preferred Card
$95 annual fee
≈$5.40
5.4%
With Rakuten Dining: ≈$10.90 · 11%
3x Chase Ultimate Rewards on dining
300 Chase Ultimate Rewards · ≈$5.40 at 1.8¢ each (valuation from Jan 2026)
After you join Rakuten Dining and link this card
Rakuten Dining, Member tier: 5% back
$5.50 as points, or $5.00 as cash (valuation from Oct 2026)
Valued as points, for members who take Rakuten Cash Back as Bilt points (free Bilt account; 50 points per $1 at Blue status, 100 per $1 from Silver up) or Amex Membership Rewards (1:1; needs another Amex card that earns Membership Rewards). Taken as cash, it is worth its face value.
A card links to one Rakuten (Rewards Network and Seated) program at a time; linking it to Rakuten Dining replaces any other.
Join Rakuten Dining
Chase Sapphire Reserve
$795 annual fee
≈$5.40
5.4%
With Rakuten Dining: ≈$10.90 · 11%
3x Chase Ultimate Rewards on dining
300 Chase Ultimate Rewards · ≈$5.40 at 1.8¢ each (valuation from Jan 2026)
After you join Rakuten Dining and link this card
Rakuten Dining, Member tier: 5% back
$5.50 as points, or $5.00 as cash (valuation from Oct 2026)
Valued as points, for members who take Rakuten Cash Back as Bilt points (free Bilt account; 50 points per $1 at Blue status, 100 per $1 from Silver up) or Amex Membership Rewards (1:1; needs another Amex card that earns Membership Rewards). Taken as cash, it is worth its face value.
A card links to one Rakuten (Rewards Network and Seated) program at a time; linking it to Rakuten Dining replaces any other.
Join Rakuten Dining

Values are estimates at CardRewards point valuations. See the best cards for dining.

Best now≈6%American Express Gold Card

About

Neighborhood Irish pub in Columbus's Lincoln Village serving pizzas, wings and appetizers, with live DJ nights on weekends.

O'Toole's Irish Pub & Grill is a neighborhood pub in the Lincoln Village area of West Columbus.

The menu centers on pizzas, wings and appetizers, and the bar runs daily happy hour drink specials.

Live DJ entertainment takes place on Friday and Saturday nights, and carryout is available by calling ahead.

Known for

Live DJ Friday and Saturday nights
Pizzas, wings and appetizers
Daily happy hour
Carryout available

Dining programs here

10 dining programs pay extra here on top of your card. Join one, link a card, and pay with that card.

Hilton (Rewards Network): pick one of 10 programs

These programs share one restaurant network, and a card can be linked to only one of them. Choose the currency you want. Every day.

Hilton Honors Dining2–8 points per $1
IHG Dine & Earn1–8 points per $1
Eat Around Town4–6 points per $1
AAdvantage Dining1–5 miles per $1
SkyMiles Dining0.5–5 miles per $1
MileagePlus Dining0.5–5 miles per $1
Atmos Rewards Dining0.5–5 points per $1
Rakuten Dining5% back
TrueBlue Dining1–3 points per $1
Rapid Rewards Dining0.5–3 points per $1

Hours

Monday	2 PM – 2 AM
Tuesday	2 PM – 2 AM
Wednesday	2 PM – 2 AM
Thursday	2 PM – 2 AM
Friday	2 PM – 2 AM
Saturday	2 PM – 2 AM
Sunday	2 PM – 2 AM

Location

4796 West Broad St · South Columbus, Columbus

Directions Apple Maps

Details

Features

Live music
Happy hour
Takeout

Good for

Dinner · Lunch

Nearby restaurants

Ding Ho Restaurant
up to12%
Asian · $$ · Westland · 1.1 mi
American Express Gold Card + Rakuten Dining
Hilton Honors Dining8xIHG Dine & Earn8xEat Around Town6x+9 more
Tee Jaye's Country Place - Columbus
up to12%
American · $ · South Columbus · 1.1 mi
American Express Gold Card + Rakuten Dining
Hilton Honors Dining8xIHG Dine & Earn8xEat Around Town6x+9 more
La Super Torta
up to12%
Mexican · $$ · South Columbus · 1.3 mi
American Express Gold Card + Rakuten Dining
Hilton Honors Dining8xIHG Dine & Earn8xEat Around Town6x+9 more
Hot Head Burritos Hilliard
up to12%
Mexican · $$ · Sweetwater · 2.4 mi
American Express Gold Card + Rakuten Dining
Hilton Honors Dining8xIHG Dine & Earn8xEat Around Town6x+9 more
Zaytoon Mediterranean Grill
up to12%
Mediterranean · $$ · South Columbus · 2.5 mi
American Express Gold Card + Rakuten Dining
Hilton Honors Dining8xIHG Dine & Earn8xEat Around Town6x+9 more
Playa Bowls Quarry Trails
up to12%
Juices/Smoothies · $$ · Griggs · 4.0 mi
American Express Gold Card + Rakuten Dining
Hilton Honors Dining8xIHG Dine & Earn8xEat Around Town6x+9 more

1 Irish restaurants in Columbus 4 restaurants in South Columbus

Some restaurant addresses, phone numbers, websites and cuisines come from Overture Maps Foundation open data (Meta and Microsoft, CDLA Permissive 2.0; Foursquare, Apache 2.0; AllThePlaces, CC0 1.0). Overture attribution Some neighbourhoods come from Who's On First boundaries (CC-BY 4.0). Who's On First licenses Some opening hours, phone numbers, websites and cuisines are © OpenStreetMap contributors (ODbL 1.0). OpenStreetMap copyright

About

Known for

Dining programs here

Hours

Location

Details

Features

Good for

Nearby restaurants

Ding Ho Restaurant

Tee Jaye's Country Place - Columbus

La Super Torta

Hot Head Burritos Hilliard

Zaytoon Mediterranean Grill

Playa Bowls Quarry Trails