Five Guys

Name: Five Guys
Address: 855 Montauk Hwy, Shirley, NY, 11967, US
Telephone: +16317919919

BurgersShirley

Reservations not listed
855 Montauk Hwy
Shirley, NY 11967
+16317919919
Website

Ways to pay here

What each card earns on your bill, best first.

Your bill$

Top dining cards

Best nowAmerican Express Gold Card
$325 annual fee
4x on up to $50,000 of eligible spend a year
≈$6.00
6%
With Upside: ≈$16.00 · 16%
4x Membership Rewards on dining
400 Membership Rewards · ≈$6.00 at 1.5¢ each (valuation from Aug 2025)
After you join Upside and link this card
Upside, Upside user tier: 20% back
$10.00 cash back
20% back, up to $10 · Upside's public offer, yours may differ
Join Upside
Chase Sapphire Preferred Card
$95 annual fee
≈$5.40
5.4%
With Upside: ≈$15.40 · 15%
3x Chase Ultimate Rewards on dining
300 Chase Ultimate Rewards · ≈$5.40 at 1.8¢ each (valuation from Jan 2026)
After you join Upside and link this card
Upside, Upside user tier: 20% back
$10.00 cash back
20% back, up to $10 · Upside's public offer, yours may differ
Join Upside
Chase Sapphire Reserve
$795 annual fee
≈$5.40
5.4%
With Upside: ≈$15.40 · 15%
3x Chase Ultimate Rewards on dining
300 Chase Ultimate Rewards · ≈$5.40 at 1.8¢ each (valuation from Jan 2026)
After you join Upside and link this card
Upside, Upside user tier: 20% back
$10.00 cash back
20% back, up to $10 · Upside's public offer, yours may differ
Join Upside

Values are estimates at CardRewards point valuations. Some dining program terms here are not yet verified. See the best cards for dining.

Best now≈6%American Express Gold Card

About

Five Guys location in Shirley, NY, offering customizable burgers, fries and milkshakes for dine-in, takeout or delivery.

This Shirley location serves burgers that can be customized in many ways, along with hand-spun milkshakes.

Fries are cooked twice in peanut oil, and peanuts are served while guests wait.

Dine-in, takeout and delivery are available.

Known for

Customizable burgers
Hand-spun milkshakes
Fries double-cooked in peanut oil
Peanuts served while you wait

Dining programs here

1 dining program pays extra here on top of your card. Join one, link a card, and pay with that card.

Upside
20% back
Upside · Every day
20% back, up to $10 · Upside's public offer, yours may differ
How Upside worksUnverified terms

Location

855 Montauk Hwy · Shirley, Shirley

Directions Apple Maps

Details

Features

Takeout
Delivery

Nearby restaurants

Applebee's - 216
up to16%
American · Shirley · 50 ft
American Express Gold Card + Upside
Upside30%

1 Burger joints in Shirley 2 restaurants in Shirley

Some restaurant addresses, phone numbers, websites and cuisines come from Overture Maps Foundation open data (Meta and Microsoft, CDLA Permissive 2.0; Foursquare, Apache 2.0; AllThePlaces, CC0 1.0). Overture attribution Some neighbourhoods come from Who's On First boundaries (CC-BY 4.0). Who's On First licenses Some opening hours, phone numbers, websites and cuisines are © OpenStreetMap contributors (ODbL 1.0). OpenStreetMap copyright