CardRewardsEditorial disclosure: CardRewards.ai is an independent comparison service. Our analysis is based on publicly available card data and is reviewed regularly by our editorial team. Card issuers do not influence our rankings or content. Last updated: May 2026.
Ranked by effective value per dollar at Casey's — including welcome offer math, redemption value, and annual fee.
Rankings are generated by our algorithm based on earn rates, point valuations, fees, and benefits — not paid placement. We don't accept compensation to rank cards higher. How we rank
Wyndham Rewards Earner Plus Card earns the top spot for Casey's purchases at 5.2¢ per dollar — a $75 annual fee, factoring in welcome offers and ongoing rewards. We ranked every card in our database against Casey's purchases using the same scoring engine that powers our search. The list below orders cards by net value to you, not by what pays the biggest affiliate commission. Cards 4–10 are still solid picks; they just trade off some of the headline value for fewer fees, broader networks, or simpler redemptions.
Barclays
Ranked by effective value per dollar at Casey's — including welcome offer math, redemption value, and annual fee.
Rankings are generated by our algorithm based on earn rates, point valuations, fees, and benefits — not paid placement. We don't accept compensation to rank cards higher. How we rank
Wyndham Rewards Earner Plus Card earns the top spot for Casey's purchases at 5.2¢ per dollar — a $75 annual fee, factoring in welcome offers and ongoing rewards. We ranked every card in our database against Casey's purchases using the same scoring engine that powers our search. The list below orders cards by net value to you, not by what pays the biggest affiliate commission. Cards 4–10 are still solid picks; they just trade off some of the headline value for fewer fees, broader networks, or simpler redemptions.
Barclays
Ranked by effective value per dollar at Casey's — including welcome offer math, redemption value, and annual fee.
Rankings are generated by our algorithm based on earn rates, point valuations, fees, and benefits — not paid placement. We don't accept compensation to rank cards higher. How we rank
Wyndham Rewards Earner Plus Card earns the top spot for Casey's purchases at 5.2¢ per dollar — a $75 annual fee, factoring in welcome offers and ongoing rewards. We ranked every card in our database against Casey's purchases using the same scoring engine that powers our search. The list below orders cards by net value to you, not by what pays the biggest affiliate commission. Cards 4–10 are still solid picks; they just trade off some of the headline value for fewer fees, broader networks, or simpler redemptions.
Barclays
Citi
Barclays
Wyndham Rewards Earner Plus Card earns 5.2¢ per dollar at Casey's, the highest in our database. The $75 annual fee pays for itself once you're spending at least the equivalent each year. It's the right pick if you want maximum value on this category and don't mind paying for a premium card.
All 10 cards ranked by effective value per dollar.
| Card | Dining Rate | Effective Value | Annual Fee | Fee Offset | Network |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wyndham Rewards Earner Plus CardBarclays | 6x Wyndham Rewards | 5.2¢/$ | $75 | $0.64 | visa |
| Citi Custom Cash CardCiti | 5% cash back | 5.0¢/$ | $0 | — | mastercard |
| Wyndham Rewards Earner CardBarclays | 5x Wyndham Rewards | 3.8¢/$ | $0 | — | visa |
| Wells Fargo Autograph Visa Credit CardWells Fargo | 3x Wells Fargo Rewards | 4.5¢/$ | $0 | — | visa |
| Citi Strata Premier CardCiti | 3x ThankYou Points | 4.5¢/$ | $95 | — | mastercard |
| PenFed Platinum Rewards Visa Signature® CardPenfed | 5x points | 4.2¢/$ | $0 | $0.64 | visa |
| Wells Fargo Autograph Journey Visa Credit CardWells Fargo | 3x Wells Fargo Rewards | 4.5¢/$ | $95 | — | visa |
| Verizon Visa CardSynchrony | 4% cash back | 4.0¢/$ | $0 | — | visa |
| Capital One Venture X Rewards Credit CardCapital One | 2x Venture Miles | 3.7¢/$ | $395 | — | visa |
| Sam’s Club World Elite Mastercard® (Club members)Synchrony | 5x points | 4.2¢/$ | $0 | — | mastercard |
Other brands in Gas Stations where the top picks above also earn well.
Want to filter by spend amount, network, or fee preference?
Open in full search with filters →Citi
Barclays
Wyndham Rewards Earner Plus Card earns 5.2¢ per dollar at Casey's, the highest in our database. The $75 annual fee pays for itself once you're spending at least the equivalent each year. It's the right pick if you want maximum value on this category and don't mind paying for a premium card.
All 10 cards ranked by effective value per dollar.
| Card | Dining Rate | Effective Value | Annual Fee | Fee Offset | Network |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wyndham Rewards Earner Plus CardBarclays | 6x Wyndham Rewards | 5.2¢/$ | $75 | $0.64 | visa |
| Citi Custom Cash CardCiti | 5% cash back | 5.0¢/$ | $0 | — | mastercard |
| Wyndham Rewards Earner CardBarclays | 5x Wyndham Rewards | 3.8¢/$ | $0 | — | visa |
| Wells Fargo Autograph Visa Credit CardWells Fargo | 3x Wells Fargo Rewards | 4.5¢/$ | $0 | — | visa |
| Citi Strata Premier CardCiti | 3x ThankYou Points | 4.5¢/$ | $95 | — | mastercard |
| PenFed Platinum Rewards Visa Signature® CardPenfed | 5x points | 4.2¢/$ | $0 | $0.64 | visa |
| Wells Fargo Autograph Journey Visa Credit CardWells Fargo | 3x Wells Fargo Rewards | 4.5¢/$ | $95 | — | visa |
| Verizon Visa CardSynchrony | 4% cash back | 4.0¢/$ | $0 | — | visa |
| Capital One Venture X Rewards Credit CardCapital One | 2x Venture Miles | 3.7¢/$ | $395 | — | visa |
| Sam’s Club World Elite Mastercard® (Club members)Synchrony | 5x points | 4.2¢/$ | $0 | — | mastercard |
Other brands in Gas Stations where the top picks above also earn well.
Want to filter by spend amount, network, or fee preference?
Open in full search with filters →Citi
Barclays
Wyndham Rewards Earner Plus Card earns 5.2¢ per dollar at Casey's, the highest in our database. The $75 annual fee pays for itself once you're spending at least the equivalent each year. It's the right pick if you want maximum value on this category and don't mind paying for a premium card.
All 10 cards ranked by effective value per dollar.
| Card | Dining Rate | Effective Value | Annual Fee | Fee Offset | Network |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wyndham Rewards Earner Plus CardBarclays | 6x Wyndham Rewards | 5.2¢/$ | $75 | $0.64 | visa |
| Citi Custom Cash CardCiti | 5% cash back | 5.0¢/$ | $0 | — | mastercard |
| Wyndham Rewards Earner CardBarclays | 5x Wyndham Rewards | 3.8¢/$ | $0 | — | visa |
| Wells Fargo Autograph Visa Credit CardWells Fargo | 3x Wells Fargo Rewards | 4.5¢/$ | $0 | — | visa |
| Citi Strata Premier CardCiti | 3x ThankYou Points | 4.5¢/$ | $95 | — | mastercard |
| PenFed Platinum Rewards Visa Signature® CardPenfed | 5x points | 4.2¢/$ | $0 | $0.64 | visa |
| Wells Fargo Autograph Journey Visa Credit CardWells Fargo | 3x Wells Fargo Rewards | 4.5¢/$ | $95 | — | visa |
| Verizon Visa CardSynchrony | 4% cash back | 4.0¢/$ | $0 | — | visa |
| Capital One Venture X Rewards Credit CardCapital One | 2x Venture Miles | 3.7¢/$ | $395 | — | visa |
| Sam’s Club World Elite Mastercard® (Club members)Synchrony | 5x points | 4.2¢/$ | $0 | — | mastercard |
Other brands in Gas Stations where the top picks above also earn well.
Want to filter by spend amount, network, or fee preference?
Open in full search with filters →